Novel Method of Transdermal Drug Delivery: Iontophoresis
Piyush K. Rekhawar*,
A.V. Chendewar, R.L. Bakal,
Santhosh Shep and Keshao Giradkar
P. Wadhwani College of Pharmacy, Yavatmal (MS), India
ABSTRACT:
The highly lipophilic nature of the skin restricts the permeation of
hydrophilic, high molecular weight and charged compounds through the stratum corneum into the systemic circulation. However, many
therapeutically active drug molecules are hydrophilic and possess high
molecular weights for example, peptides. Iontophoresis
is an alternative drug and cosmetic delivery system. A low-level electrical
current is applied to a similarly charged drug or cosmetic solution. Iontophoresis repels the drug ions which diffuse through
the skin to the underlying tissue. In contrast to passive transdermal patch
drug delivery, iontophoresis is an active (electrically
driven) method that allows the delivery of water-soluble ionic drugs that would
not be effectively absorbed through the skin without application of a voltage.
This presentation provides a general overview on iontophoresis
with the emphasis on possible advantages associated with this system,
principles, mechanisms associated with them, summarization of different
application and factors affecting iontophoresis,
evaluation parameter used to determine the
feasibility of using iontophoretic delivery devices
to facilitate the transdermal transport of hydrophilic charged macromolecules
of peptides, such as vasopressin, and proteins, such as insulin, across the
skin.
KEYWORDS: Transdermal; Iontophoresis.
INTRODUCTION:
Iontophoresis simply defined is the application of an electrical
potential that maintains a constant electric current across the skin and
enhances the delivery of ionized as well as unionized moieties. This technique
is capable of expanding the range of compounds that can be delivered transdermally. Transdermal drug delivery offers many
advantages over other routes of conventional drug delivery. However, only a few
drug candidates have been successfully developed into suitable transdermal
formulations because of the formidable skin barrier. An effort to facilitate
drug molecule transport across Skin includes the use of chemical and physical
methods for flux enhancement. Transdermal iontophoresis
is a technology that enhances drug transport across the skin barrier with the
assistance of an electric field. The mechanisms of transdermal iontophoresis include electrophoresis (electric field
charge interaction), electro osmosis (electric field induced solvent flow) and electroporation (increasing the porosity of skin due to
electric field). Direct current (DC) iontophoresis
with a constant current approach is the most common form of transdermal iontophoretic drug delivery1.
ADVANTAGES:
Along with
the benefits of bypassing hepatic first pass effect, and higher patient
compliance, then additional advantages that the iontophoretic
technique offers can be summarized as follows:
1. Delivery
of ionized and unionized drugs
2. Enabling
continuous or pulsatile delivery of drug (depending
on the current applied)
3.
Permitting easier termination of drug delivery
4. Offering
better control over the amount of drug delivered since the amount of Compound
delivered depends on applied current, duration of applied current, and area of
skin exposed to the current
5.
Restoration of the skin barrier function without producing severe skin
irritation
6.
Improving the delivery of polar molecules as well as high molecular weight
compounds
7. Ability to be
used for systemic delivery or local (topical) delivery of drugs
8. Reducing
considerably the inter and intra-individual variability since the rate of drug
Delivery is more dependent on applied current than on stratum corneum characteristics2
Principles of iontophoresis:
The iontophoretic technique is based on the general principle
that like charges repel each other. Thus during iontophoresis,
if delivery of a positively charged drug (DC) is desired, the charged drug is
dissolved in the electrolyte surrounding the electrode of similar polarity,
i.e. the anode in this example (Fig. 1). On application of an electromotive force
the drug is repelled and moves across the stratum corneum
towards the cathode, which is placed elsewhere on the body. Communication
between the electrodes along the surface of the skin has been shown to be
negligible, i.e. movement of the drug ions between the electrodes occurs
through the skin and not on the surface. When the cathode is placed in the
donor compartment of a Franz diffusion cell to enhance the flux of an anion, it
is termed cathodal iontophoresis
and for anodal iontophoresis, the situation would be
reversed.
Neutral
molecules have been observed to move by convective flow as a result of
electro-osmotic and osmotic forces on application of electric current .Electro migration of ions during iontophoresis
causes convective solvent motion and this solvent motion in turn ‘drags’
neutral or even charged molecules along with it. This process is termed as
electro-osmosis. At pH values above 4, the skin is negatively charged, implying
that positively charged moieties like Na+ molecules will be more easily
transported as they attempt to neutralize the charge in the skin to maintain electroneutrality. Thus the movement of ions under
physiological conditions is from the anode to the cathode. For loss of each cation (sodium ion in this case) from the electrode in this
process, a counterion, i.e. an anion, Cl- moves in the opposite direction from the cathode to the
anode. It is the transport number of each ion, which describes the fraction of
the total current transferred by the ion and depends on the physicochemical
properties of the respective ions. +Na is greater than -Cl and also the skin facilitates movement of Na+ more than Cl-, hence there is a net increase in the NaCl in the cathodal compartment
and net decrease in NaCl on the anodal side. Due to this
electrochemical gradient, osmotic flow of water is induced from the anode to
the cathode. If any neutral drug molecules are present at the anode at this
time they can be transported through the skin along with the water. Such water
movement often results in pore shrinkage at the anode and pore swelling at the
cathode3,4
MECHANISM:
Like charges
repel. Hence the charged ion is repelled into the skin from a similar charged
electrode. The skin being negatively charged at physiological pH acts as a cationselective membrane and favors movement of cations through anodal iontophoresis.
Anodal iontophoresis also causes convective motion of
the solvent occurring in response to movement of counterions.
This process of electro-osmosis is involved in the motion of neutral compounds
as well as positively charged ions. Due to the complex nature of iontophoretic delivery, a number of attempts have been made
to define the rate of iontophoretic delivery. The
Nernst-Planck equation has been used with modifications to predict iontophoretic enhancement ratios (ratio of steady state
flux in presence of electric potential and in absence of potential) as the
original equation lacks a term for convective electroosmotic
flow. Srinivasan and Higuchi and Pikal
and Shah studied the contributions of osmotic flow and incorporated this fact
into several equations.
The increased
flux during iontophoresis would include:
1. Flux due to
the electrochemical potential gradient across the skin;
2. Change in the
skin permeability due to the electric field applied; and
3. Electroosmotic Water flow and the resultant solvent drag.
J ionto = J
electric +
J passive + J
convective
J electric
is the flux due to electric current
application; J passive was
the flux due to passive delivery through skin; and Jconvective was
the flux due to convective transport due to electro osmosis.
Pathways of
molecular transport in iontophoresis:
Skin appendages
which include sweat glands and hair follicles are postulated to be involved in
the major pathways of drug transport during iontophoresis.
Evidence from studies comparing iontophoretic
delivery in hairless and regular rats suggests a much larger contribution of
the sweat glands and ducts as opposed to hair follicles in permeation. Other
pathways which have been shown to be involved in iontophoretic
delivery include paracellular transport especially
for water and uncharged polar solutes, artificial shunts due to temporary
disruption of the organized structure of the stratum corneum,
potential-dependent pore formation has also been observed .5
Reverse iontophoresis: a noninvasive diagnostic tool:
The versatility of iontophoresis can be appreciated from the symmetry of the
technique, which allows molecules to move in and out of the skin under the
influence of electro-osmosis. The acceptance of iontophoresis
as a standard diagnostic procedure for cystic fibrosis opened up a new avenue
for non- invasive diagnosis and monitoring of biomolecules
and ions from the body through reverse iontophoresis.
Glucowatch (Cygnus Inc., USA) is a wrist-worn device that can
continuously detect and monitor glucose levels through skin non
invasively and is awaiting approval from the US Food and Drug Administration.
This, if introduced, will alleviate the discomfort of diabetics that is
associated with the conventional finger prick method of glucose measurement,
although will not replace the information obtained from standard home blood
glucose monitoring devices. Reverse iontophoresis
also offers some promise for developing a skin sensitivity testing system that
measures PGE2 levels through the skin. Very recently, scientist have
demonstrated the possibility of measuring systemic amino acid levels,
particularly phenylalanine, using reverse iontophoresis,
which may be useful for diagnosing metabolic disorders. There are, however,
some issues that need to be addressed: for example, the development of sensors
that can measure very low analyte concentrations
precisely and reliably; the reduction in equilibration and measurement times;
and the internal calibration of the system so as to develop useful and
practical diagnostic systems. In spite of the fact that reverse iontophoresis is a later entrant to the field than iontophoresis, it is far ahead of iontophoresis,
holding enormous commercial potential as a routine noninvasive diagnosis and
monitoring technology.6
Factors affecting iontophoresis:
I. Composition of
formulation:
Ø
Concentration of
drug solution
Ø
pH of donor
solution
Ø
Ionic strength
Ø
Viscosity
Ø
Presence of
co-ions
II. Physicochemical properties
of the permeant:
Ø
Molecular size
Ø
Charge
Ø
Polarity
Ø
Molecular weight
III. Experimental
conditions:
Ø
Current strength
Ø
Current profile
Ø
Electrode material
Ø
Biological Factors
Ø
Regional blood
flow
Ø
Condition of skin and
Skin pH
§
Drug concentration: Increasing drug concentrations results in greater drug delivery to a certain degree
§
pH: The pH of the
solution can be adjusted and maintained by larger molecules, such as
ethanolamine: ethanolamine hydrochloride rather than the smaller hydrochloric
acid and sodium hydroxide. An increase in ionic strength of the system will
also increase the competition for the available current, especially since the
active drugs are generally potent and present in a smaller concentration than
these extraneous ion
§
Ionic strength: as increase in ionic strength will decrease drug
delivery,
§
Viscosity: The migration of the drug is inversely related to the
viscosity.
§
Presence of co-ions : If buffer ions are included, they compete with the drug for the
delivery, decreasing the quantity of drug delivered, especially since buffer
ions are generally smaller and more mobile than the larger active drug
§
Physicochemical variable: The drug should be water soluble, low-dose and ionizable with a high charge density. Smaller molecules are
more mobile but large molecules are also iontophoresable
§
Current strength: Since current can easily be controlled by the use of
electronics, it is a convenient mean to control delivery of drugs to the body.
However, a large increase beyond the permissible limits causes irritation and
can damage the skin
§
Current profile: Mostly, in the studies conducted on animals in vitro, current is kept constant
and very low voltage of about 10 V is applied
§
Electrode material: Iontophoretic
studies have been conductedusing both platinum wire
and Ag/AgCl wires. However, platinum electrodes or
other inert electrodes like nickel or stainless steel have been found to cause
pH drift and gas bubbling due to decomposition of water and thus causing
production of H+ and OH- ions
§
Regional blood flow: During iontophoresis, the
dermal blood supply determines the systemic and underlying tissue solute
absorption. Blood supply however, does not appear to affect the drug
penetration fluxes through the epidermis during iontophoretic
delivery.
§
Condition of skin: In iontophoresis, skin
condition also affects the penetrating properties of permeant.
Feldman et al., showed that the
passive diffusion of hydrocortisone occured maximally
fromthe area with numerous hair follicle while lesser
in area with thickest stratum corneum7,8
Applications of iontophoresis:
1. Treatment of hyperhydrosis:
Hyperhydrosis (also called hyperhidrosis) is a
condition that most often results in excessive sweating in the hands and feet.
Tap water iontophoresis is one of the most popular
treatments used in this condition. The procedure uses a mild electrical current
that is passed through tap water to temporarily shut off sweat glands. A hand
and foot is each placed in a different water basin and the electric current is
gradually increased to the required level and maintained for 20 min followed by
a gradual decrease. The underlying mechanism of how iontophoresis
helps treat this ailment is not fully understood. According to one hypothesis, iontophoresis may induce hyperkeratosis of the sweat pores
and obstruct sweat flow and secretion (although no plugging of the pores has
been found). Other proposed mechanisms include impairment of the
electrochemical gradient of sweat secretion and a biofeedback mechanism.
Successful induction of hypohidrosis by tap-water iontophoresis requires the application of 15–20 mA to each palm or sole for 30 min per session for 10
consecutive days, followed by one or two maintenance sessions per week .The
advantage of using tap water iontophoresis is that
the patient can conduct the procedure at home.9
2. Topical delivery:
The ability to
control the delivery rates of drugs by changes in current makes iontophoresis an attractive technique to use.Yamashita et al. studied the efficacy of iontophoretic delivery of calcium for treating hydrofluoric
acid-induced burns.The authors conducted the
experiments using rats as in vivo models.Hydrofluoric
acid burns were induced by dispensing 50% hydrofluoric acid on the backs of the
rats under anesthesia and the rats were divided into five groups: control group
(untreated) one group treated with 2.5% calcium gluconate
jelly applied once for the duration of the experiment on the burn area on the
back of the rat, third group treated with intradermal
and subcutaneous calcium gluconate injection and the
last group was subjected to calcium chloride iontophoresis
at 1.5 V.Burn areas were used as a measure to assess
the efficacy of treatment and pathologic findings were classified
microscopically into five stages at 1 week: stage 1, epidermal burn; stage 2,
superficial dermal burn; stage 3, deep dermal burn; stage 4, full-thickness
burn; and stage 5, burn affecting the skeletal muscle. They observed that burn
areas were significantly reduced by iontophoresis
more than any other mode of calcium administration, and iontophoresis
was more efficacious than topical or injection therapy for experimental
hydrofluoric acid burns.Topical delivery of
anesthetics during dermal surgery remains the most common topical application
of iontophoresis.
Hydrochloride
salts of anesthetics of the amide type like lidocaine,
bupivacaine, etidocaine, mepivacaine, prilocaine and ropivacaine have been widely studied. Lidocaine
been successfully formulated in an iontophoretic
patch for dermal anesthesia (Vyteris, Inc., Fairlawn,
NJ, USA).10,11
3. Non-invasive monitoring of glucose:
Electro osmotic
flow generated by application of low level current has been used for extraction
of glucose through the skin. As the direction of glucose flow is in the
opposite direction (in outward direction in skin) to conventional iontophoresis, it is called reverse iontophoresis.
This property in combination with in situ glucose sensors has been used in GlucoWatchw Biographer (Cygnus Inc.,Redwood City, CA, USA) . This device allows
noninvasive extraction glucose across the skin, allowing a diabetic’s glycemia to be evaluated every 10 min over several hours.
The Biographer is constituted of a small Wristwatch device containing sampling
and detection devices, electronic circuitry, and a digital display. As the
negatively charged skin at physiological pH is subject to iontophoresis
by the electrodes in the device, the sodium ions move from the anode towards
the cathode and create a convective flow. Glucose thus gets transported to the
cathode with the solvent where it is oxidized by glucose oxidase
to release hydrogen peroxide. This is then detected by the custom designed
biosensor in the system. Research in the near future could link the detection
level to release of insulin as per the needs of the patient which would be
another substantial step towards creating a ‘closed loop biofeedback’ drug
delivery system. Another study by Merino et al. has demonstrated sampling of
phenylalanine by reverse iontophoresis. The
limitations of these noninvasive biological sampling techniques would be in
their ability to measure reliably and accurately low levels of analytes.12,13
4. Delivery of antisense oligonucleotides:
Antisense oligonucleotides bind to the mRNA of the disease-causing
genes and inhibit their expression so as to block synthesis of disease related
proteins. These oligonucleotides are usually
delivered by injection and hence an alternative route for systemic delivery is
desirable. The transdermal delivery route is attractive because it may enable
the localized delivery of the oligonucleotide into
skin layers, which is desirable in conditions such as dermatitis and psoriasis.
IL-10 over-expression for example, is one of the important pathogenic factors
in skin lesions resulting from atopic dermatitis (AD). Thus, the regulation of
IL-10 production is a potential solution for immunotherapeutic intervention in
AD. A study has been conducted by Sakamoto et al. which included the topical
delivery of an antisense oligonucleotide for mouse
IL-10 and the observation of the therapeutic effect on the AD skin lesions of
mice. By using iontophoresis the authors were able to
deliver 30% of the applied dose locally to the dermis and the epidermis.
Topically delivered oligonucleotide decreased the
levels of mRNA and protein of IL-10 in the lesions of mice and the dorsal
lesions disappeared with repeated topical application. It was concluded that
this delivery system offered potential therapy for established dermatitis
patients.14
5. Peptide delivery:
This seems to be
one of the most promising applications of iontophoretic
transdermal delivery. Transdermal delivery itself offers the advantages of
bypassing first pass metabolism and gastrointestinal degradation as well as
patient compliance over the existing oral and parenteral
routes of administration for peptide delivery. An additional advantage that it
offers specifically for proteins and peptides is the avoidance of strong proteolytic conditions as found in the gastrointestinal
tract. Chien et al. have studied the delivery of oligopeptide, vasopressin, with transdermal periodic iontotherapeutic system (TPIS). The TPIS procedure
delivered a d. c. pulse with various combinations of waveforms, frequency,
on/off ratio and current intensity for specified application time. The results
suggested that in the absence of TPIS, the rate of skin permeation of
vasopressin was negligible but in the presence of TPIS, not only did the flux
increase 190-fold but the lag time was also reduced by almost 9 h. Over the
years a wide range of proteins and peptides such as LHRH, salmon calcitonin, and human parathyroid hormone have been studied
for transdermal delivery via iontophoresis.5,15,16
REFERENCES:
1.
Kevin Li et al. Evaluation of constant current alternating current iontophoresis for transdermal drug delivery Journal of
Controlled Release 110 (2005) 141– 150
2.
Y. Wang et al. Transdermal iontophoresis:
combination strategies to improve transdermal iontophoretic
drug delivery European Journal of Pharmaceutics and Biopharmaceutics
60 (2005) 179–191.
3.
Aarti Naik et al. Transdermal drug delivery: overcoming the
skin’s barrier function research focus reviews PSTT Vol. 3, No. 9 September 2000
4.
B.W. Barry et al. Novel mechanisms and devices to enable successful
Transdermal drug delivery European Journal of Pharmaceutical Sciences 14 (2001)
101–114
5.
Yie W. Chien et al. facilated
transdermal delivery of therapeutics
peptides and Protein by iontophrotic delivery device,
Journal of Controlled Release, 13 (1990) 263-278
6.
Ramesh Panchagnula et al. Transdermal iontophoresis
revisited Current Opinion in Chemical Biology 4 (2000) 468–473
7.
Sanjula Baboota et al. Iontophoresis - An Approach for Controlled Drug Delivery:
A Review, Current Drug Delivery, 4(2007) 1-10
8.
Reena Rai et al. Iontophoresis in dermatology, Dermatology 4(2005) 236-241
9.
Jl shen et al a new strategy
of iontophoresis for hyperhydrosis,
journal of American academy of dermatology 22 (1990) 239-241.
10. J. Singh, H.I. Maibach et al. Topical Iontophoretic Drug Delivery in vivo:
Historical Development, Devices and Future Perspectives,] Dermatology vol.187, no. 4, 1993
11.
Philip W. Ledger et al. Skin
biological issues in electrically enhanced Transdermal delivery, Advanced Drug Delivery Reviews, 9
(1992) 289-307
12.
Ramesh Panchagnula et al. Transdermal iontophoresis
revisited, Current Opinion in Chemical Biology, 4 (2000) 468–473
13.
M. Paranjape et al. A PDMS dermal
patch for non-intrusive transdermal glucose sensing, Sensors and Actuators A 104
(2003) 195–204
14.
Yannic B. Schuetz et al. Effect of amino acid sequence on transdermal
iontophoretic peptide delivery, European Journal of
Pharmaceutical Sciences 26 (2005) 429–437
15. Richard H. Guy et
al. Structure–permeation relationships
for the non invasive Transdermal delivery of cationic peptides by iontophoresis european
journal of pharmaceutical sciences 29 (2006) 53–59
16. Aarti Naik et al. Effect of amino acid sequence on transdermal iontophoretic peptide delivery, European Journal of
Pharmaceutical Sciences , 26 (2005) 429–437
Received
on 19.01.2010
Accepted on 17.02.2010
© A&V Publication all right reserved
Research Journal of Pharmaceutical
Dosage Forms and Technology.
2(3): May-June 2010, 215-219